Compare
AI audit, SOC 2, pen test, ISO 42001 or AIUC-1?
Enterprise buyers ask AI vendors for several kinds of assurance. They check different things, and only some of them test what your AI actually does. Here they are side by side.
Five kinds of assurance, side by side
| Assurance | What it checks | Who issues it | Typical cost | Typical time | Tests your AI’s behavior? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SOC 2 Type 2 | Whether your company’s security controls, and any of availability, processing integrity, confidentiality and privacy you include, worked over a period | A licensed CPA firm, against the AICPA Trust Services Criteria. A report, not a certificate | $30,000 to $80,000 in the first year | About 6 to 12 months to a first report, including a 3 to 12 month observation window | No |
| Pen test | Exploitable flaws in your application, APIs and infrastructure | A security testing firm. A findings report, no certificate | $9,000 to $20,000 for a mid-size SaaS app | About 1.5 to 2 weeks of testing for a mid-size SaaS app | Not usually; only if the scope adds AI-specific tests |
| ISO/IEC 42001 | Your AI management system: the policies, roles, and risk and impact processes you use to govern AI | An accredited certification body. A certificate, with yearly surveillance audits | $15,000 to $75,000 or more, all in, for a small company | About 3 to 12 months, depending on how much you have to build | No. It checks how you manage AI, not what your AI does |
| AIUC-1 certification | Controls in six areas (data and privacy, security, safety, reliability, accountability and society), plus adversarial testing of your AI agent | AIUC (the Artificial Intelligence Underwriting Company), with audits by firms AIUC accredits, such as Schellman | Not published | AIUC’s pages say 4 to 12 weeks from kickoff, longer if you start from zero. The certificate is valid for one year, with quarterly retests | Yes. AIUC tests for jailbreaks, prompt injection, data leakage, hallucinations and unsafe tool calls |
| Independent AI audit (Autogeny) | Pass or fail on the failures you can’t afford and how often your AI fails, in a test copy of your running system, including prompt injection, your AI leaking one customer’s data to another, and harmful agent actions. Then how well it does its job, and whether a cheaper model would do as well | Autogeny, an independent firm that sells no models, guardrails, runtime protection or testing platform and takes no referral fees. A report, not a certificate | $20,000 per AI workflow, $27,000 per tool-using agent | About 3 to 4 weeks | Yes. That is what it’s for |
AIUC-1 expects an external pen test of your AI endpoints (B004). Ask your pen-test firm to include them; we can share the AI test cases from your audit.
Costs and times are typical published ranges, mostly from companies that sell these services, so ask each provider for a quote. Sources: Scrut, SOC 2 cost; Scrut, SOC 2 timeline; Blaze Information Security, pen test cost; ComplyJet, ISO 42001 cost; AIUC-1; AIUC-1 certification; AIUC-1 auditor guide.
Which do you need?
A buyer asks for SOC 2.
Get SOC 2. Nothing else on this page replaces it, and an AI audit doesn’t cover your infrastructure or company controls.
The questionnaire asks how you test your AI.
SOC 2 and a pen test don’t answer that. An independent AI audit does, with evidence mapped to the AI questions in the security questionnaire your buyer sends you, the CSA AI Controls Matrix and the OWASP Top 10 for LLM Applications.
A buyer asks for AIUC-1 by name.
Pursue the certification. An Autogeny audit doesn’t certify you, but its readiness check goes through every AIUC-1 requirement first, with your test evidence where testing applies, so you can see the likely gaps. Our free AIUC-1 readiness checklist lists every requirement and the evidence to gather.
A buyer asks for a certified AI management system.
That’s ISO 42001. It covers your policies and processes; an AI audit covers what your AI actually does.
More answers are on the questions page, and prices and scope on the audit page.
Not sure which one your buyer needs?
Bring the questionnaire to a free 30-minute scoping call. We’ll tell you which questions an AI audit answers and which need something else.